Quantcast
China Using Fish to Eat Pollution, Then Selling the Fish PDF Print E-mail
Written by Hank Green   
Monday, 25 February 2008

China looks to be solving an environmental disaster by moving the toxins up the food chain into its residents. Let's hope that they won't be exporting the carp that will be gobbling up Lake Chao's pollution problem.

Lake Chao (Chau Hu) is one of China's five largest fresh water lakes. As such, it drives all nearby industry, once primarily fishing. But along with China's rapid economic growth, of course you can't forget China's rapid environmental decline. Lake Chao's fish stocks have plumetted in the last 10 years, as untreated sewage and effluent from hundreds of factories have turned the lake into one of China's biggest environmental disasters.

But don't worry, they've got a plan! Actually, if you're planning on buying fish from China, you should definitely worry. China has just begun the release of 1.5 million silver carp fry. These fish thrive in low-oxygen waters (like Lake Chao) and enjoy eating the algae that has flourished in the toxic, high-nitrogen pollution of the lake. The Chaohu Fishery Administration estimates that each fish will consume up to 100 lbs of algea, and all the toxic chemicals contained in it, before reaching full size.

At that point, the fish will be sold into the market as food. Thus a boon to the fishing industry and the environment at an immeasurable cost to public health.

OK, China isn't exactly known for it's intelligent environmental policies but this is ridiculous. To imagine that simply moving the toxins up the food chain into people could be a solution seems outrageous. But there it is.

In the end, there is no way to decrease the amount of pollution in China's water without dealing with the source of that pollution, something that Prefecture officials are loathe to do, as it trades rapid development for health, safety and the environment. As for now, we only have one suggestion. Don't eat anything that comes from China.

Via Yahoo News

Comments
Add NewSearch
robert saint amour   | 70.66.194.xxx | 2008-02-24 20:57:55
china is a cesspool and will only get worse as long as americans continue to encourage walmart to buy 75% of their merchandise there
Craig Mackintosh - Biomagnification     | 91.148.9.xxx | 2008-02-25 12:59:06
A lot of people are not aware what it means for chemicals to move up the food chain. It's not a good look. The following post makes it easy to understand 'biomagnification':

http://www.celsias.com/2007/04/02/pesticides-and-you/
Kmuzu - King Kmuzu     | 71.49.223.xxx | 2008-02-25 15:40:07
Oh come on .. that is pure evil genius beautiful .. I wonder if that was planned from the start or if the plant operators were like, "What are we going to do with all these screwed up, mutant fish?"

Thank you for making my day brighter.

King Kmuzu
Anonymous   | 76.119.81.xxx | 2008-02-25 16:14:37
"china is a cesspool and will only get worse as long as americans continue to encourage walmart to buy 75% of their merchandise there"

Yes, put no responsibility on the people and government of China, let's blame the Americans instead! That's much easier.
Ebony   | 82.7.252.xxx | 2008-02-25 16:33:56
Perhaps the toxins the fish injest are chemically altered as they process them, rendering them mostly harmless.

Sure the people will be eating it, but once it's been through a biological system that filters oxygen out of water, I'm not entirely convinced there's no method to the madness here.
Craig Mackintosh - Biomagnification     | 91.148.9.xxx | 2008-02-25 16:38:05
Ebony - er... suggest you read the post I referred to in the 'biomagnification' comment above. Here it is again:

http://www.celsias.com/2007/04/02/pesticides-and-you

Animals don't 'filter' toxins. They get more and more concentrated as they go up the food chain.
D M - Question...   | 71.49.51.xxx | 2008-02-26 09:43:03
Your article would carry more weight if you actually mentioned a toxin -- 'untreated sewage' does not mean deadly poison. If poop bioaccumulated, we'd all have been dead back when we were single-celled organisms. If the main problem is nitrates, it sounds like China is on the ball. The algae are sucking up all the oxygen, killing the native plants and animals. Eat the algae and you solve the problem. Not all toxins act the same way as mercury.
jonolan - Ebony may be right.     | 63.241.158.xxx | 2008-02-26 10:19:37
Ebony may well be right in this case. Biomagnification is only possible in the case of poisons that are not broken down by the organism in question. The article only cites various sources of nitrates, which will be broken down by both the algae and by the carp in question.
Craig Mackintosh - Excess Nitrates are dangerous     | 91.148.14.xxx | 2008-02-26 10:39:43
"Pesticide residues are not the only problem arising from modern agricultural techniques. Increasingly, nitrate levels in vegetables are causing concern, although most attention so far has been focused on nitrates in water supplies
Craig Mackintosh - Last one     | 91.148.14.xxx | 2008-02-26 10:45:02
I give up. My comments keep getting clipped. Read more on the implication of nitrates here: http://tinyurl.com/24lzqw
and know that the original post is talking about many more kinds of toxic chemicals, not just nitrates.
Pete - Interesting tactic   | 193.133.69.xxx | 2008-02-26 10:54:24
I think it is a good crazy idea.

This is to get you to think..
For it to work you would need to ensure that the ones that own the factory have to eat the fish as well.
when they have a wife/husband and children who become unwell, they will do something quickly about the pollution.
same as if you were to take all the rubbish each week and dump it in your back garden for a year.. you'd learn how bad it can be to not recycle and not use/have organic waste/wrapping.
daretoeatapeach - Sorry it doesn't work that wa     | 66.124.95.xxx | 2008-02-26 13:27:15
Pete:The people who run the factories will be able to afford the non-tainted fish. Only the poor will choose to eat the fish with poison. For example, look at the U.S. where the upper middle class can afford Organic food while the poor eat Ramen noodles and mercury-tainted fish. Or look at villagers who's sustenance stocks are fished by outsiders and they are sold back the skeletons of what they used to fish to eat.
Tattler - Lake Chaohu is not as you depi     | 218.185.203.xxx | 2008-02-26 14:08:58
I have been to Lake Chaohu many times. It is a rather beautiful lake that does suffer from having a surplus of Algae blooms during the summer months. To suggest "...untreated sewage and effluent from hundreds of factories have turned the lake into one of China's biggest environmental disasters," is far from the truth.

The fact that you do not even name the province in which it is located, nor any of the recent measures taken by the Anhui government to ensure pollution and algae growth in the lake is kept to a minimum, suggests you have done little research into the subject.

Perhaps you have a case of Yellow Peril Fever which induces knee-jerk negative responses to any news from China.
V   | 65.26.247.xxx | 2008-02-26 17:35:18
Well, their growth can be directly attributed to American trade. They have officially favored status and they make virtually EVERYTHING we buy. Of course China is to blame for their failure to regulate, but we support them every time we go shopping because people are too ignorant to realize they can buy quality American-made goods.
Andy - American Farmed Tilapia   | 68.29.159.xxx | 2008-02-26 17:36:09
http://www.deliciousorganics.com/Controversies/tilapia.htm

Eat this lately?

Yellow Peril Fever indeed.
Jing - you are so biased   | 221.207.250.xxx | 2008-02-26 20:26:28
you don't know China at all, you think you know the truth just by reading those stupid news?
MoMo - Mr.   | 24.190.96.xxx | 2008-05-01 14:16:17
We,the USA & the European Union,have to help all the developing countries such as CHINA,India,Brazil and so on for solving any pollution(especially
as water,air & soil).
The only thing we can do is "not blaming/insulting",but "helping".
We have to remember "how bad" was the pollution happened in the developed countries before?
Great   | 89.109.39.xxx | 2008-06-27 04:34:10
buy Cialis
Cialis generic
generic Cialis
Cialis online
buy Cialis online
buy Levitra
Levitra generic
generic Levitra
Levitra online
buy Levitra online
Tony   | 218.186.9.xxx | 2008-08-12 17:40:38
I so love when people come in defense, while ignoring the truth about the place. So What... he did not name the province, that does not mean one has not been there.
Plain and simply put China is one GIANT CESSPOOL of a country, the land and people are dirty, and all the points of the blog are true.
I love these people who go to China for a weeks vacation and become experts on this country. I have been to 57 cities in China(do I have to name every one, and every province they are in for people to believe me) and almost 100 factories in China. The country is disgusting. every day I spend there, I go home and spend the first 30 minutes blowing, dust, dirt and other black garbage out of my nose, before putting a ring around my shower and bath tub from the dirt my body has collected during the day.
How long does one have to spend in a country, how many things do they need see before the truth can be said.
As for those of you who say America, and Europe are at fault you are correct, but for the wrong reason. these people ( the Chinese), but the reason we are at fault is for political correctness, not for buying the products, tell them they are a cesspool, cause them to loose face and they will change, cater to these people and they only become arrogant, that is truth for you China can do no wrong people, if you don't believe me try it, then tell me I am wrong.
But there are no worries, the companies will begin to leave China soon, and go to Vietnam, so that that too can be turned into the same. Then China will revert back 20 years,and maybe, just maybe clean itself up.
ryllwc - wow gold     | 123.145.166.xxx | 2008-09-09 23:15:09
Professional WoW Power Leveling store,We offer cheap WoW Power Leveling,cheap World of Warcraft WoW Power Leveling,).Free Guide to help you Buy WoW Gold,WoW Power Leveling, and WoW Gold, sessions are really cheap, normally a lot less than the WoW Gold, minimum wage offered in the US because most WoW Gold, of the workers who are wow gold,wow gold,leveling are based in China.WoW Gold, Not only that but they normally are buy WoW Gold able to level faster than the Cheap WoW Gold average player WoW Gold, considering they have workers rotating Cheap WoW Gold shifts along with many many practices in the game. Cheap WoW Gold One of the best part of leveling a brand new character is Cheap WoW Gold that you will have a fresh reputation of the WoW Gold and WoW Gold would be able to name the character as you like. World of warcraft Power Leveling,warcraft Power Leveling,World of warcraft Power Leveling,warcraft Power Leveling,age of conan gold,aoc gold,buy aoc gold,cheap aoc gold,aoc power leveling,age of conan power leveling,aoc power leveling,aoc gold,age of conan gold,age of conan power leveling,guild wars gold,lotro gold,lotro gold,lotr gold,lotr gold,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos,maplestory mesos, maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maple story mesos,maplestory mesos,runescape gold,runescape money,aoc gold,age of conan gold,aoc gold, age of conan gold,aoc gold,FFXI Gil,final fantasy gil,oil purifier,rolex replica,replica rolex,chongqingyantai,evening dresses,evening gowns,wedding dresses,bridal gowns,wedding gowns,cocktail dresses,Bridesmaid dresses,prom dresses,formal dresses,girls clothes,baby boy clothes,baby boy clothing,baby girl clothes,baby girl clothing,dog clothes,dog collarsPromotional items,Promotional products,Wedding dresses,Pet supplies,Dog clothes,[url=http://www.lidodo.com]
nitrile gloves - nitrile gloves     | 210.192.102.xxx | 2008-09-21 11:01:37
nitrile gloves
spray booth
warhammer gold - warhammer gold     | 122.224.195.xxx | 2008-09-21 23:13:24
yunfeiyang   | 221.221.15.xxx | 2008-09-22 03:14:07
jh592mx In the eve of National Day, the majoritywow gold of the players to launch the most affordable buy wow power levelingconcessions of Warcraft gold and members plan to buy the more expensive the wow goldmore! wow power leveling

(A) buy concessions: wow gold
1) one-time purchasewow power leveling of gold reached 200 yuanRolex RMB or more, with the exception of membership discount, the sending of 9.8 credit! World of Warcraft goldRolex Watch
2) one-time purchasewow power leveling of gold reached 500 replica rolexyuan RMB or more, with the rolex replicaexception of membership discount, the sending of 9.5 credit! wow power levelingRunescape Gold
3) every day to buy wow power levelinggold to reach a total of 1,000 yuan RMB (which may include a different server), sent to 1% of the Fan Dian. You deposit money in the form of your account (1U = 1 yuan currency RMB, may purchase any gold server). * Note: The amount of gold purchased on the day of a three-day standards related to the application of effective customer service. RuneScape Money
4) the Watches Rolexamount of gold wow power levelingcoins to buy a day to reach a total of 3,000 RMB wow power leveling(which may include a different server), sent to 2% of the Fan Dian. You deposit money in the form of your Rolex Watchesaccount (1U = 1 yuan currency RMB, may purchase any gold server). Note: The amount of gold purchased on the day ofWatch Rolex a three-day standards related to the rs goldapplication of effective customer service. * Note: The discount is limited to buy online or pay the money, does not apply to money gifted pay.
wowgolds987 - wowgolds987     | 121.32.18.xxx | 2008-09-23 04:21:41
To let the world into a dark wizard? Mmoinn.com purchase of wow
gold , endless darkness of the non-stop through the purchase of precious stones and the use of
the moon, you can always be the dark. mmoinn to provide you with
world of warcraft sale , World of warhammer gold is most valuable form of currency in World of Warcraft. mmoinn you can save huge wow money to purchase gems of the moon, you can find a gray and Feralas Valley, where there are dense forests of wow power leveling .
wow gold - wow gold     | 122.234.50.xxx | 2008-09-23 23:49:14
One of the most wow gold the best wow gold systems in buy wow gold World of Warcraft's buy wow gold design is it cheap wow gold player-based cheap wow gold auction system. Much like an internal world of warcraft gold eBay, the auction houses fast wow gold of the world link sell wow gold all the major cities age of conan gold together in an aoc gold open trade ffxi gil environment. Characters residing warhammer gold in the ruins known as runescape gold Undercity tibia gold can trade their goods with the orcs swg credits and trolls lotro gold of Orgrimmar. 2moons dil Meanwhile, dwarves maple story mesoswow goldcheap wow goldbuy wow gold of Ironforge eve isk can sell ore and lineage 2 adena goods eq2 plat to their elven wow power leveling friends on wow power leveling the far off city of Darnassus power leveling. Alliance and world of warcraft power leveling Horde characters wow power level can even trade amongst wow leveling

themselves, wow leveling in the power leveling goblin run wow gold free cities of buy wow gold Gadgetzan, Everlook cheap wow gold and Booty world of warcraft gold Bay. The economy wow power leveling of World of power leveling is a robust, living entity, controlled world of warcraft power leveling entirely by the players of the world.
wowgolds987 - wowgolds987     | 121.32.18.xxx | 2008-09-24 03:13:15
Mmoinn contains a great wealth of good, it gives you cheapest wow gold let you in the highest mountains in the mountains of Britain's Dun Morogh find more wealth. Dun Morogh biting wind will always accompany you. Steep cliff and the snow-covered lake,
which is the Yeti, Troll and the Beast entrenched, but in this densely barren of snow and ice of the country, some additional surprises. You can find mmoinn in warcraft gold and wow power leveling . mmoinn is a huge support to help you save a good place, together buy wow
gold you to experience the mmoinn The pleasant surprise.
dfgfdgs   | 222.210.174.xxx | 2008-09-24 21:16:09
Want to go to tibet tour? You can rely on us! We are expert in tibet travel. based in Tibet 15 years experience, 600 private groups operated! So join us for your wondrous tour in tibet! Are you interested in mysterious Lhasa travel to tibet? Why not take our Lhasa tibet trekking? You can appreciate the holiness of Lhasa .tibet tour guide with our well-connected itinerary and leave a memorable recollection over life. These are China Lhasa Tibet tangka packages with personal local tibet map, and private vehicle with driver + hotels + entrance fees and meals as listed for your party based on minimum 2 travelers. For single person, please email us for new quotations. For any questions, please feel free to contact our customer team with our prompt and personalized travel services.
wow gold - wow gold     | 220.250.9.xxx | 2008-09-26 22:42:32
WAR gold
warhammer online gold
Buy WAR gold
Buy warhammer gold
Buy warhammer online gold
warhammer gold
WAR Accounts
warhammer Accounts
warhammer online Accounts
Buy WAR Accounts
warhammer Accounts for sale
Warhammer Power Leveling
Warhammer Online Power Leveling
War Power Leveling
Buy Warhammer Power Leveling
Warhammer PowerLeveling
Cheap Warhammer Power Leveling
Cheap Warhammer Online Power Leveling
Buy War Power Leveling
Warhammer EU Power Leveling
Cheap Warhammer Gold
Cheap Warhammer online gold
Buy Cheap Warhammer Gold
Buy WAR Gold
Warhammer EU Gold
Warhammer EU Power Leveling
Warhammer EU CD Key
Warhammer EU Accounts
Warhammer CD Key
Warhammer online CD Key
Warhammer Timecard
Buy Warhammer Time Card
Warhammer 60 days Time Card
Cheap WAR Accounts
Cheap warhammer Accounts
Cheap warhammer online Accounts
Buy Cheap WAR Accounts
buy Warhammer CD Key
buy Warhammer online CD Key
cheap Warhammer CD key
warhammer time card
Warhammer prepaid time card
sell wow gold - sell wow gold     | 222.76.52.xxx | 2008-09-26 22:55:49
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
sell wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
wow gold
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
sell wow cd key
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
trade wow gold
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow gold trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
wow trade
sell maple story mesos
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maple story mesos[/url]
sell maple story mesos
sell maple story mesos
sell maple story mesos
sell maple story mesos
sell maple story mesos

sell maplestory mesos
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maplestory mesos[/url]
sell maplestory mesos
sell maplestory mesos
sell maplestory mesos
sell maplestory mesos
sell maplestory mesos

sell maple story gold
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maple story gold[/url]
sell maple story gold
sell maple story gold
sell maple story gold
sell maple story gold
sell maple story gold

sell maple story money
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maple story money[/url]
sell maple story money
sell maple story money
sell maple story money
sell maple story money
sell maple story money

sell maplestory gold
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maplestory gold[/url]
sell maplestory gold
sell maplestory gold
sell maplestory gold
sell maplestory gold
sell maplestory gold

sell maplestory money
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]sell maplestory money[/url]
sell maplestory money
sell maplestory money
sell maplestory money
sell maplestory money
sell maplestory money

maplestory trade
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]maplestory trade[/url]
maplestory trade
maplestory trade
maplestory trade
maplestory trade
maplestory trade

maple story trade
[url=http://www.allgametrade.com/ sell_maple_story_mes
os.html]maple story trade[/url]
maple story trade
maple story trade
maple story trade
maple story trade
maple story trade

maple story mesos
maple story mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maple story mesos[/url]
maple story mesos
maple story mesos
maple story mesos

maplestory mesos
maplestory mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maplestory mesos[/url]
maplestory mesos
maplestory mesos
maplestory mesos

maple story gold
maple story gold
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maple story gold[/url]
maple story gold
maple story gold
maple story gold

maplestory gold
maplestory gold
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maplestory gold[/url]
maplestory gold
maplestory gold
maplestory gold

maple story money
maple story money
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maple story money[/url]
maple story money
maple story money
maple story money

maplestory money
maplestory money
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maplestory money[/url]
maplestory money
maplestory money
maplestory money

buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]buy maple story mesos[/url]
buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos

buy maplestory mesos
buy maplestory mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]buy maplestory mesos[/url]
buy maplestory mesos
buy maplestory mesos
buy maplestory mesos

maple story
maple story
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maple story[/url]
maple story
maple story
maple story

maplestory
maplestory
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maplestory[/url]
maplestory
maplestory
maplestory

buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]buy maple story mesos[/url]
buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos
buy maple story mesos

cheap mesos
cheap mesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]cheap mesos[/url]
cheap mesos
cheap mesos
cheap mesos

maple story shop
maple story shop
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]maple story shop[/url]
maple story shop
maple story shop
maple story shop

cheap msmesos
cheap msmesos
[url=http://www.cheap-msmesos.com/ buy_maplestory_mesos
.html]cheap msmesos[/url]
cheap msmesos
cheap msmesos
cheap msmesos

Runescape
Runescape
Runescape
Runescape
Runescape
Runescape
Runescape

Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold
Runescape Gold

Runescape Money
Runescape Money
Runescape Money